12, pp. Algorithm for Sequencing Experiments in Drug Discovery”, Informs Journal here to download main paper) (Click Instead of creating The paper develops an approximation of the knowledge gradient for batch learning to guide the initial discrete decision (size and shape). Gradient for Maximizing Expensive Continuous Functions with Noisy Observations We do this by developing a continuous approximate of the knowledge gradient. Ryzhov, I. O. and W. B. Powell, “Bayesian Active Learning With Basis Functions,” SSCI 2011 ADPRL - 2011 IEEE Symposium on Adaptive Dynamic Programming and Reinforcement Learning, Paris, April, 2011. S. Dayanik, W. Powell, and K. Yamazaki, “Index policies for discounted bandit problems with availability constraints,” Advances in Applied Probability, Vol. This paper describes a method for applying the knowledge gradient to a problem with a very large number of alternatives. knowledge gradient does not identify the best choice - it identifies the measurement It is useful to divide these models into three fundamental For more on this project, click here. This paper uses the knowledge gradient for dynamic programs where the value function is now approximated using a linear model. http://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10.1137/12086279X. This condition is useful for verifying consistency (c) Informs. the tuning of two continuous parameters, which required approximately six We have generalized this work to high-dimensional models where we use sparse-additive linear models. We propose the KG(*) algorithm, which maximizes the average value of information, and show that it produces good results when there is a significant S-curve effect. for Operations Research and Management Science, 2011 (c) John Wiley and Sons. This problem 47, (click here to download paper) (Click here for online supplement). Considerable attention has been This paper extends this idea to problems with continuous alternatives. From offline learning to online learning: The knowledge-gradient policy was originally derived for off-line learning We consider the optimal learning problem of optimizing an expensive function with a known parametric form but unknown parameters. Optimal learning – This research addresses the challenges of collecting information, when information (observations, simulations, laboratory and field experiments) are expensive. One of the most famous problems in information collection is the multiarmed bandit problem, where make a choice (out of a discrete set of choices), observe a reward, and use this observation to update estimates of the future value of rewards. This is our newest area of research, with a number of papers on the way. Some sample applications include: How do you discover the best drug to treat a disease, out of the thousands of potential combinations? Optimal Learning develops the needed principles for gathering information to make decisions, especially when collecting information is time-consuming and expensive. This produces a nonconcave surface that we have to maximize. For example, imagine we are trying to determine the best ad to put on a website. The knowledge gradient can produce poor learning The goal is to choose compounds to test that allow us to estimate the parameters theta as quickly as possible. the continuous parameters to optimize a device). The campus has a dedication to green buildings, reducing its impact on the environment and providing optimal space for learning, teaching, researching, and working. The goal is to try different ads to learn these parameters An athlete improves over time, as do teams that work together over time. This condition is useful for verifying consistency of adaptive sequential sampling policies that do not do forced random exploration, making consistency difficult to verify by other means. a function at different levels of aggregation. maximizes the average value of information, and show that it produces good often, ensuring consistency, i.e., that a globally optimal future decision 180-195 (2012). SDSU has a Climate Action Plan that commits campus to achieving operational carbon neutrality by 2040 and full carbon neutrality by 2050. Optimal learning represents the problem of making observations (or measurements) in an efficient way to achieve some objective. OCBA is new. D. Negoescu, P. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “The Knowledge Gradient Algorithm for Sequencing Experiments in Drug Discovery”, Informs Journal on Computing, Vol. of adaptive sequential sampling policies that do not do forced random Frazier, P. I., and W. B. Powell, “Paradoxes in Learning: The Considerable attention has been given to the on-line version of this problem, known popularly as the multiarmed bandit problem, for which Gittins indices are known to be optimal for discounted, infinite-horizon versions of the problem. (c) Informs. In this study, we focus on a Bayesian approach known as optimal learning with knowledge gradient, which selects alternatives that maximizes the expected value of information. We research how to help laboratory scientists discover new science through the use of computers, data analysis, machine learning and decision theory. In addition to general nonlinear models, we study special cases such as logistics regression. then identify the information that has the highest impact on the economic problem. Experimental under which measurement policies sample each measurement type infinitely The knowledge gradient policy is introduced here as a method for solving the ranking and selection problem, which is an off-line version of the multiarmed bandit problem. If you are interested in the real theory, see. A Bayesian model is set up to capture the uncertainty in our Yingfei Wang, K. G. Reyes, K. A. you have a normally distributed belief about the value of each choice. I am an Associate Research Scholar at the Operations Research and Financial Engineering Department at Princeton University. Consistency of the knowledge-gradient policy was shown previously, while the consistency result for Using Bayesian Statistics and Decision Theory, OL helps you decide on the next experiment based on your objective and what it has learned about the system so far. a machine for airport security that can sense explosives and it works poorly, Encyclopedia for Operations Research and Management Science, 2011 (c) John of an observation, taking into account the possible change in the estimate "The Correlated Knowledge Gradient for Simulation Optimization of Continuous Parameters Using Gaussian Process Regression." This work is summarized in. infinite-horizon versions of the problem. This paper can handle low-dimensional vectors of continuous parameters. At the moment, this website focuses on our work on the knowledge gradient, a simple, elegant concept for collecting information. Scientific Computing, Vol. given to the on-line version of this problem, known popularly as the multiarmed the information gained by the measurement. We derive a one-period look-ahead policy for online subset selection problems, where learning about one subset also gives us information about other subsets. In addition, we may also be receiving rewards or incurring costs, which have to be balanced against the value of the information being gained. Ilya Ryzhov, Boris Defourny, Warren Powell, “Ranking and Selection Meets Robust Optimization,” Winter Simulation Conference, 2012. Support Princeton Splash You have a way of collecting information, but it is expensive, and you have a limited amount of time to learn the best path. Here, we combine the frequentist Lasso regularization methodology to identify the most important parameters: Yan Li, Han Liu, W.B. need to find the best molecular compound to solve a particular problem (e.g. Our certified teachers will get to know you on a personal basis for the optimal learning experience. classes: Brief discussions in the weights w^g_x which have to be recomputed after each observation. We then revisit the knowledge gradient algorithm, which allocates measurements based on the marginal value of information. 2410-2439 (2008). The campus has a dedication to green buildings, reducing its impact on the environment and providing optimal space for learning, teaching, researching, and working. Below is a partial list: Learning Optimal Levels for the Reservoir in Yunnan, China, Ethiopian Famines— Learning Solutions for Sustainable Agriculture, Finding Effective Strategies in a Multi-Strategy Hedge Fund, Waffles and Dinges and Knowledge Gradient, Oh My! I.O. The knowledge gradient is developed for a locally parametric belief model. We propose the KG(*) algorithm, which is found in the limit. model (let's assume a linear regression), but we do not know the values of the This paper addresses the problem of learning when the belief model is nonlinear in the parameters, motivated by a problem in materials science. I am a member of the Computational Stochastic Optimization and Learning (CASTLE) Lab group working with Prof. Warren Powell on Stochastic Optimization and Optimal Learning with applications in Emergency Storm Response and Driverless Fleets of Electric Vehicles. Princeton University. Optimal learning (OL) addresses these issues in a systematic way to navigate experiment space and achieve your objective. theta as quickly as possible. Together they form a unique fingerprint. Most of the applications that we have considered here for online supplement). the density of particles) to maximize a metric (reflexivity of a surface). Once we know the parameters, we can estimate the value After your N measurements, you have to choose what appears to We use the distances between local minima to perform scaling of the steepest descent algorithm. knowledge gradient is both myopically and asymptotically optimal. 1, pp. Discovery). E. Barut and W. B. Powell, “Optimal Learning for Sequential Sampling with Non-Parametric Beliefs". The challenge is that measurements take This paper derives the knowledge gradient when the belief model is captured using kernel regression, a class of nonparametric statistical models. We use a Bayesian model that captures expert indexed by i. a particular material or sensor within the device). But there are situations where it can work poorly, as we demonstrate in Section 5.2 below. 7, No. 1, pp. Vol. A Bayesian model is set up to capture the uncertainty in our beliefs about the convergence of the model. 377-400 (2008). Powell, W. B. Frazier, P., W. B. Powell and S. Dayanik, “A Knowledge Gradient The paper shows that just as with problems with independent beliefs, the knowledge gradient is both myopically and asymptotically optimal. The multi-armed bandit problem is a venerable topic in optimal learning and has inspired some of the pioneering work in the ﬁeld. 1360-1367. Scott, Warren, P. I. Frazier, and W. B. Powell. We model the economic decision we are trying to make, and To formulate an optimal learning problem, we have to first create We compare the method against Huang's adaptation of sequential kriging to problems with noisy measurements. D. Negoescu, P. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “The Knowledge Gradient Algorithm for Sequencing Experiments in Drug Discovery”, Mes, M., P. I. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “Hierarchical Knowledge Gradient for Sequential Sampling,”, DC-RBF (Dirichlet Clouds with Radial Basis Functions), I. Ryzhov, W. B. Powell, P. I. Frazier, “The knowledge gradient algorithm for a general class of online learning problems,”, I. Ryzhov, W.B. This paper investigates a stopping rule based on the knowledge gradient concept. here for online supplement), The S-curve effect - Handling the nonconcavity of information. 2410-2439 (2008). alternatives might number in the tens of thousands (of molecules), hundreds a belief about each alternative (known as a "lookup table belief model"), We compare the method against Huang’s adaptation of sequential kriging to problems with noisy measurements. the size and shape of nanoparticles) followed by batch learning of a secondary tunable parameter (e.g. Health sciences – Projects in health have included drug discovery, drug delivery, blood management, dosage decisions, personal health, and health policy. A common problem arises when we have to tune a set of continuous set of parameters. We also computed the knowledge gradient when we are using kernel 585-598 (2009) (c) Informs (Click (2012). 213-246 (2008) (c) Informs. The paper shows that just as with problems with independent beliefs, the If we want an estimate of the here for online supplement). “Asymptotically Optimal Bayesian sequential change detection and identification rules.” Annals of Operations Research (M. Katehakis, ed.) (as shown to the right) with different levels of uncertainty about each alternative, The knowledge gradient policy is a method for determining which of a discrete set of measurements we should make to determine which of a discrete set of choices we should make. Learning nonlocal constitutive models with neural networks, Xu-Hui Zhou, Jiequn Han, Heng Xiao, … Optimal learning addresses the challenge of how to collect set of choices we should make. Powell, “The Knowledge Gradient Policy using a Sparse Additive Belief Model,” Working paper, Department of Operations Research and Financial Engineering, Princeton University, 2015. 346-363, 2011. (2012). It actually slightly outperforms the best available approximation of Gittins The paper presents two optimal blending strategies: an active learning method that maximizes uncertainty reduction, and an economic approach that maximizes an expected improvement criterion. The method is motivated by the There are applications where the underlying alternative is steadily getting better in the process of observing it. Click here for a spreadsheet implementation of the knowledge gradient for independent, normally distributed beliefs, (Click This paper develops and tests a knowledge gradient algorithm when the underlying belief model is nonparametric, using a broad class of kernel regression models. 346-363, 2011. the ranking and selection problem, which is an off-line version of the multiarmed Our decision rule is easy to compute, and performs competitively against other learning policies, including a Monte Carlo adaptation of the knowledge gradient policy for ranking and selection. Central to the concept of optimal learning is a measurement policy. 1, pp. Software. killing cancer cells). This problem differs from traditional ranking and selection, in that the implementation decision (the path we choose) is distinct from the measurement decision (the edge we measure). Uncertainty Quantification (to appear). Manage knowledge with Bayesian Statistics This theory paper describes an adaptation of the knowledge gradient for general linear programs, extending our previous paper on learning the costs on arcs of a graph for a shortest path problem. of the ad (the topic, number of words, graphics, ...). The knowledge gradient can be computed for each link in the network using at most two shortest path calculations (and often one). The knowledge gradient can produce poor learning results in the presence of an S-curve. Syllabus (2012) - Princeton enjoys 12 week semesters, so this syllabus may look a bit short to many faculty. using Gaussian Process Regression,” SIAM J. on Optimization (to appear). produce the highest value if you only have one more measurement (the knowledge S Dayanik, W. B. Powell and K. Yamazaki “An Asymptotically Optimal Strategy in Sequential Change Detection and Identification Applied to Problems in Biosurveillance” Proceedings of the 3rd INFORMS Workshop on Data Mining and Health Informatics, (J. Li, D. Aleman, R. Sikora, eds. If we have five alternatives The KG policy with independent beliefs is extremely easy to compute (we The paper puts a prior on the distribution of indicator variables that capture whether a coefficient is zero or not. the left (below), we have to find the maximum of the knowledge gradient surface 22(4), pp. Non-Parametric Belief Models,” J. The only policy which is competitive with KG seems to be interval estimation, (c) Informs. a particular material or sensor within the device). size and shape) followed by a series of experiments (e.g. The knowledge gradient using a linear belief model, D. Negoescu, P. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “The Knowledge Gradient We consider the situation where information is collected in the form of a linear combination of the objective coefficients, subject to random noise. 3, pp. The First, it provides the first finite-time bound on the performance of the knowledge gradient for offline ranking and selection problems. done in a spreadsheet. We then revisit the We have extended the knowledge gradient to two classes of nonparametric which measures the marginal value of a measurement in terms of the value of We consider an optimal learning problem where we are trying to learn a function that is nonlinear in unknown parameters in an online setting. 2931-2974, 2011. we represent our belief about an alternative using linear regression (known A single run of the model (which uses adaptive learning from approximate dynamic programming) requires more than a day, so the paper also introduces methods to product results without a full run. So alternative 2 may be much more attractive to evaluate 4, pp. Within simulation, he views the design of simulation optimization algorithms as an optimal learning problem, and is developing new simulation optimization algorithms with optimal average-case performance. Learning in the presence of a physical state. Problem sets (2012) - This zipped file includes latex files and associated software (spreadsheets and matlab code). 2009. how to compute the knowledge gradient for problems with correlated beliefs. Global Optimization (to appear). This makes it possible to provide meaningful guidance to find the best out of the website. This makes it very easy for others to add new problems, and new algorithms. Evaluating the Knowledge for Sequential Sampling,” J. The power of the knowledge gradient is the ease with which it can be 188-201, 2011. The KG policy is also effective on finite horizon problems. Some sample applications include: Each of these problems require making observations (measurements) to knowledge gradient with independent beliefs, in addition to outperforming Policy for Correlated Normal Beliefs,” Informs Journal on Computing, above, but the original paper on this topic is, P. Frazier, W. B. Powell, S. Dayanik, “The Knowledge-Gradient information is time consuming and expensive. A little bit of information may teach you nothing, and you may have to make an investment in information beyond a certain threshold to actually have an impact. - This paper uses the knowledge gradient for dynamic programs where the value function is now approximated using a linear model. Semidefinite programming relaxations are used to create efficient convex approximations to the nonconvex blending problem. ), 2008. An easy tutorial is contained in the article. This paper applies the sparse KG algorithm (see paper immediately above) to the problem of identifying the structure of RNA molecules. exploration, making consistency difficult to verify by other means. I. Ryzhov, W.B. The work is described in, D. Negoescu, P. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “The Knowledge Gradient Algorithm for Sequencing Experiments in Drug Discovery”, Informs Journal on Computing, Vol. Wang, Y. W. B. Powell, K. Reyes, R. Schapire, “Finite-time analysis for the knowledge-gradient policy, and a new testing environment for optimal learning,” Working paper, Department of Operations Research and Financial Engineering, Princeton University. is particularly easy to apply. Classes typically run between 30 and 40 students, all of whom would have taken a course in probability and statistics. Click here. 2931-2974. The knowledge gradient using a nonlinear belief model. The sampling component of the derived composite rule is the same as the previously introduced LL1 sampling rule, but the stopping rule is new. The knowledge gradient can be adopted to the problem of making We propose a Bayesian strategy for resolving the exploration/exploitation dilemma in this setting. We would like to predict how many ad clicks an ad will receive based on attributes The paper establishes asymptotic optimality for off-line versions of the problem and proposes a computationally tractable algorithm. In this paper, we derive a knowledge with Correlated Knowledge-Gradients," Winter Simulation Conference, December, 4, pp. Students are required to take a total of five courses and earn at least B- for each course: one of the “Foundations of Statistics” courses, one of the “Foundations of Machine Learning” courses, and three elective courses. which will do the most to identify the best choice. This work is based on the paper above (Mes on problems where the beliefs about different alternatives are correlated. The project requires that they pick a problem where the collection of information is time-consuming or expensive. This was an invited tutorial on the topic of optimal learning, and be the best based on your current belief. introduction to the knowledge gradient concept. asymptotically optimal. We may pose a regression take days to run). The paper provides bounds for finite measurement budgets, and provides experimental work that shows that it works as well as, and often better, than other standard learning policies. In this paper, we present an index problem for the case where not all the choices are available each time. B. Defourny, I. O. Ryzhov, W. B. Powell, “Optimal Information Blending with Measurements in the L2 Sphere". Behaving optimally in such problems is also known as optimal learning. B361-B381, DOI: 10.1137/140971117, 2015. W. B. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Abstract: Collecting information in the course of sequential decision-making can be extremely challenging in high-dimensional settings, where the number of measurement budget is much smaller than both the number … 585-598 (2009) (c) Informs. on a graph, in which we use sequential measurements to rene Bayesian estimates Operations Research, Vol 59, No. 47, No. killing cancer cells). an impact. I use the last three lectures (depending on the size of the class) to allow students to present their projects (without numerical results), so that the rest of the class sees the diversity of problems. in Operations Research, Chapter 10, pp. We develop the knowledge gradient for optimizing a function when our belief is represented by constants computed at different levels of aggregation. DOI: 10.1137/090775026. bandit problem. experimentation or running a time consuming simulation (some business simulators Global Optimization (to appear). Learning when the alternatives are continuous. The paper shows that this policy is myopically optimal (by construction), but is also asymptotically optimal, making it the only stationary policy that is both myopically and asymptotically optimal. We are developing methods to handle problems where the number of potential here to download main paper). Policy for Correlated Normal Beliefs,” Informs Journal on Computing, collection. 3, pp. The paper uses the strategy of solving a sampled belief model, where the prior is represented by a sample of possible parameters (rather than our standard use of multivarite normal distributions). Offline learning arises when we have a budget for finding the best possible solution, after which have to use the solution in a production setting. Wiley and Sons. Finding the best team to compete in an invent. We study the joint problem of sequential change detection and multiple hypothesis testing. Not only will you learn valuable skills, our emphasis on career training leads to the shortest time to hire. is to say that trying one alternative can teach us something about other alternatives. runs of the model. The knowledge gradient with independent beliefs. As a result, it is sometimes important to make an observation just because the observation is available to be made. of each are given below. We have previously developed the knowledge gradient with correlated beliefs for discrete alternatives. Numerical examples are provided to verify the asymptotic optimality and the speed of convergence. The value of information can be a concave function in the number of Our first effort used an approximation method based on estimating of finding the best molecular compound to cure cancer (see Drug The knowledge gradient for nonparametric belief models: Mes, M., P. I. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “Hierarchical Knowledge Gradient Tutorial: Optimal Learning for the laboratory sciences, An optimal learning video tutorial (by Warren Powell), The knowledge gradient for online and offline learning, Learning with continuous alternatives (parameter tuning), Learning with a robust objective function, P. Frazier, W. B. Powell, S. Dayanik, “The Knowledge-Gradient 1492-1502. testing different densities) that can be run in batch model. 1344–1368 http://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10.1137/12086279X. 3, pp. The new method performs well in numerical experiments conducted on an energy storage problem. If we evaluate the level Below we provide an overview of our current research in the knowledge gradient, organized as follows: Our research has focused on the idea of the knowledge gradient, 2, pp. 49, No. This (primarily theoretical) paper extends the paper above on learning the coefficients of a linear program. This produces a nonconcave surface that we have to maximize. Optimization under Uncertainty, Approximate Dynamic Programming, Optimal Learning, Applications in Energy, Health, Laboratory Science, Operations, Transportation Thomas Pumir Graduate Student Online learning arises when we are in a production setting, and we have to live with the costs or rewards, but we want to learn as we go. the final solution. by j) and a series of small sequences of atoms ("substituents") represents a fairly easy introduction to the general field of information beliefs about the convergence of the model. This paper extends this idea to problems with continuous alternatives. random variables changes suddenly at some unobservable time to one of nitely many distinct alternatives, and one needs to both detect and identify the change at the earliest possible time. This paper uses a discrete, lookup table representation of the belief model. Powell, "Information collection on a graph," decision (the path we choose) is distinct from the measurement decision B. Cheng, A. Jamshidi, W. B. Powell, Optimal Learning with a Local Parametric Approximations, J. Mes, M., P. I. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “Hierarchical Knowledge Gradient for Sequential Sampling,” J. Parametric models - We can further divide these according to: Low-dimensional (small number of parameters), High-dimensional - Here we use a sparse-additive belief model. 3, pp. The KG policy also works -. P. Frazier, W. B. Powell, S. Dayanik, “The Knowledge-Gradient Policy for Correlated Normal Beliefs,” Informs Journal on Computing, Vol. indices (by Gans and Chick) on problems for which Gittins indices should Ryzhov, I. O., W. B. Powell, “Approximate Dynamic Programming with Correlated Bayesian Beliefs,” Forty-Eighth Annual Allerton Conference on Communication, Control, and Computing, September 29 – October 1, 2010, Allerton Retreat Center, Monticello, Illinois., IEEE Press, pp. It turns out that there is a very simple, elegant relationship between the knowledge gradient for offline learning, and the knowledge gradient for online learning. We consider the ranking and selection of normal means in a fully sequential Bayesian context. Our estimate of the function at any point is given by a weighted sum of estimates at different levels of aggregation. Ryzhov, I. and W. B. Powell, “Bayesian Active Learning with Basis Functions,” IEEE Workshop on Adaptive Dynamic Programming and Reinforcement Learning, Paris, April, 2011. In this setting, we have to make a tradeoff between the costs or rewards we receive, and the value of information that we acquire that we can use for future decisions. ***** Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the 2021 summer research experiences in the Laboratory Learning Program will not be offered in person or remotely. We offer the following modules for download: In 2015, we introduced MOLTE, Modular Optimal Learning Testing Environment, which is a Matlab-based environment for testing a wide range of learning algorithms for problems with discrete alternatives, on a wide range of problems. We propose a new exploration strategy based on the knowledge gradient concept from the optimal learning literature, which is currently the only method capable of handling correlated belief structures. The paper develops a knowledge gradient policy for guiding an initial design decision (e.g. 4, pp. 517-543 (2014). knowledge gradient algorithm, which allocates measurements based on the Instead of maximizing the expected value of a measurement, we can adapt the knowledge gradient to maximize the worst outcome. Optimal control with learning on the fly We exhibit optimal control strategies for settings in which the underlying dynamics depend on a parameter that is initially unknown and must be learned. An initial investigation of this idea is. "The Knowledge Gradient for Optimal Learning," A common technique for dealing with the curse of dimensionality in approximate dynamic programming is to use a parametric value function approximation, where the value of being in a state is assumed to be a linear combination of basis functions. In this paper, we derive a knowledge gradient policy for on-line problems, and show that it very closely matches the performance of Gittins indices for discounted infinite horizon problems. Ryzhov, I. O. and W. B. Powell, “Bayesian Active Learning With Basis Functions,” SSCI 2011 ADPRL - 2011 IEEE Symposium on Adaptive Dynamic Programming and Reinforcement Learning, Paris, April, 2011. We propose computationally efficient sequential decision rules that are asymptotically either Bayes-optimal or optimal in a Bayesian fixed-error formulation, as the unit detection delay cost or the misdiagnosis and false alarm probabilities go to zero, respectively. raise our belief about the level of toxin in nearby locations. we want to evaluate the alternative that offers the greatest chance of improving In most applications, our belief about mu_x may be correlated We consider Bayesian information collection, in which a measurement policy collects information to support a future decision. 21, No. Frazier, P. and W. B. Powell, “The knowledge gradient stopping rule for ranking and selection,” Proceedings of the Winter Simulation Conference, December 2008. DOI 10.1007/s10898-013-0050-5. This paper uses a discrete, lookup table representation of the belief model. 60, No. There are many applications that require models that are nonlinear in the parameters. This is a rule that tells us which action xwe should take next in order to observe something new. Powell, W. B. and P. Frazier, "Optimal Learning," TutORials Like other Bayesian approaches, the knowledge gradient uses subjective prior beliefs on … We can use this belief model to estimate a function that we are We show that the resulting decision rule is easily computable, and present experimental evidence that the policy is competitive against other online learning policies. After your N measurements, you have to choose what appears to be the best based on your current belief. This sections highlights some applications we have encountered, partly from research, partly from teaching, and partly from our own need for optimal learning algorithms in the context of comparing and tuning algorithms. Our work here includes: Si Chen, K-R G. Reyes, M. Gupta, M. C. McAlpine, W. B. Powell, “Optimal Learning in Experimental Design Using the Knowledge Gradient Policy with Application to Characterizing Nanoemulsion Stability,” SIAM J. We do this by developing a continuous approximate of the knowledge gradient. of contamination in one location and it measures high, we are likely to 585-598 (2009) (c) Informs, (Click guides this search by always choosing to measure the choice which would Although the page constraints limited the scope, it covers the 2, 712-731 (2011). Observations of the function, which might involve simulations, laboratory or field experiments, are both expensive and noisy. Powell, "Information collection on a graph," Operations Research, Vol 59, No. loss, and the knowledge-gradient policy with independent normal priors. Finding the optimal solution of a linear program assumes that you have accurate information on costs (among other things). This work is summarized in. SDSU has a Climate Action Plan that commits campus to achieving operational carbon neutrality by 2040 and full carbon neutrality by 2050. We consider the optimal learning problem of optimizing an expensive function with a known parametric form but unknown parameters. The knowledge gradient policy guides this search by always choosing to measure the choice which would produce the highest value if you only have one more measurement (the knowledge gradient can be viewed as a method of steepest ascent). (click here to download main paper) (Click here for online supplement). a problem with a very large number of alternatives. Frazier, that this policy is myopically optimal (by construction), but is also asymptotically Experimental work shows that it can produce a much higher rate of convergence than the knowledge gradient with independent beliefs, in addition to outperforming other more classical information collection mechanisms. we might lower our evaluation of other devices that might use similar technologies This often arises when we have to find the set of parameters that will produce the best results for a model. demonstrate the use of this sufficient condition by showing consistency belief models. The presentation focuses more on the knowledge Motivated by a problem in laboratory experimentation, this paper considers the problem where there is an initial choice (e.g. We have found that most applications exhibit correlated beliefs, which Equal Opportunity and Nondiscrimination at Princeton University: Princeton University believes that commitment to principles of fairness and respect for all is favorable to the free and open exchange of ideas, and the University seeks to reach out as widely as possible in order to attract the ablest individuals as students, faculty, and staff. A fresh perspective of learning is to introduce a mini-max objective. Optimal Learning Optimal learning represents the problem of making observations (or measurements) in an efficient way to achieve some objective. including the classical bandit theory. For larger problems, we need specialized algorithms. We can choose the weights in the linear combination, a process we refer to as information blending. You may want to minimize costs, minimize delays or find the best match between a model and historical metrics. A proof of convergence is provided. A proof of convergence is provided. Ryzhov, I. O., W. B. Powell, “Approximate Dynamic Programming with Correlated Bayesian Beliefs,” Forty-Eighth Annual Allerton Conference on Communication, Control, and Computing, September 29 – October 1, 2010, Allerton Retreat Center, Monticello, Illinois., IEEE Press, pp. gradient. a number of the most popular heuristic policies. of thousands (of features for a car or computer) or infinite (setting 188-201, 2011. ), and is summarized in, E. have a budget of N measurements to evaluate each choice to refine your distribution By considering the sampling and stopping problems jointly rather than separately, we derive a new composite stopping/sampling rule. In some application, it is useful to have a stopping rule for an information collection problem. The knowledge gradient, using a parametric belief model, was used to sequence experiments while searching for the best compound to cure a form of Ewing's sarcoma. 10,000 molecular compounds after just 100 experiments. The knowledge gradient is not an optimal policy for collecting information, but these properties suggest that it is generally going to work well. The problem is closely related to learning in the presence of a physical state, since the initial decision (size and shape) set the stage for the second decision (density) that is run in batch. Machine Learning Research, Vol.12, pp. The knowledge gradient policy is a method for determining which of collects information to support a future decision. SIAM Journal on Optimization 21, No. 4, pp. 1, pp. We may have a belief mu_x about each x. Vol. Cite this reference as: Warren B. Powell, Reinforcement Learning and Stochastic Optimization and Learning: A Unified Framework, Department of Operations Research and Financial Engineering, Princeton University, 2019. You have a budget of N measurements to evaluate each choice to refine your distribution of belief. Optimal Learning is a rich field that includes contributions from different communities. A single run of the model (which A common challenge in the calibration of simulation model is that we 23, No. 22(4), pp. Scientific Computing (to appear). The knowledge gradient has to compute the expected value The knowledge gradient with correlated beliefs (offline learning, discrete alternatives), P. Frazier, W. B. Powell, S. Dayanik, “The Knowledge-Gradient DOI: 10.1137/090775026. P. Frazier and W. B. Powell, “Consistency of Sequential Bayesian Sampling Policies” SIAM J. and Optimal Driver Commute, Optimizing the Price of Apps on the iTunes Store, Ordering Products for Sale in a Small Business Setting: Learning Policies for Princeton Training is considered a top technical training institution. Information Collection,” SIAM J. on Control and Optimization, Vol. This model, called DC-RBF, approximates a function by representing the domain using a series of clouds, which avoids storing the history. We have previously developed the knowledge gradient with correlated beliefs for discrete alternatives. (the edge we measure). Career Coaching. This makes it possible to compute the knowledge gradient for problems with correlated beliefs. Local minima are located close to points that have been previously measured, so we use these points to guess at the locations of local maxima and then use a simple gradient search algorithm starting from each of these points. If we test a machine for airport security that can sense explosives and it works poorly, we might lower our evaluation of other devices that might use similar technologies (e.g. 21, No. 21, No. Let an alternative x be a discrete number 1, ..., M where Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'The Eighty Five Percent Rule for optimal learning'. results in the presence of an S-curve. The story that was originally used to motivate the problem (and gave the problem its name) is not really an important application, but is useful for understanding the basic idea behind the problem. Ryzhov, I., W. B. Powell, “A Monte-Carlo Knowledge Gradient Method for Learning Abatement Potential of Emissions Reduction Technologies,” Winter Simulation Conference, 2009. Imagine that you want to find the shortest path between two points, but you do not know the times on the links. work shows that it can produce a much higher rate of convergence than the These two cases are characterized by a fundamental combinatorial parameter of a learning problem: the VC (Vapnik-Chervonenkis) dimension. choices to learn a regression model. “The Correlated Knowledge Gradient for Simulation Optimization of Continuous Parameters Using Gaussian Process Regression.” SIAM Journal on Optimization 21, No. 346-363, 2011. 180-195 (2012). (click You Most of the applications that we have considered introduce the dimension of correlated beliefs. ComputAtional STochastic optimization and LEarning. Frazier, P., W. B. Powell and S. Dayanik, “A Knowledge Gradient Policy for Sequential Information Collection,” SIAM J. on Control and Optimization, Vol. M. D. Rossetti, R. R. Hill, B. Johansson, A. Dunkin, and R. G. Ingalls, eds, 2009, pp. We give a sufficient condition marginal value of information. 5, pp. He works on applications in simulation, e-commerce, medicine, and biology. Powell, “Information collection on a graph,” Operations Research, Vol 59, No. Ryzhov, I. and W. B. Powell, “The Knowledge Gradient Algorithm For Online Subset Selection,” IEEE Conference on Approximate Dynamic Programming and Reinforcement Learning (part of IEEE Symposium on Computational Intelligence), March, 2009. In order to provide an optimal learning environment for the students, we ask that parents do not attend classes with their children. I. Ryzhov, W. B. Powell, P. I. Frazier, “The knowledge gradient algorithm for a general class of online learning problems,” Operations Research, Vol. Ryzhov, W.B. Below are some general purpose routines that we have developed. 23, No. of the knowledge gradient policy for ranking and selection. This paper introduces the idea of using the knowledge gradient within a dyamic program, which effectively means in the presence of a physical state. Marginal Value of Information and the Problem of Too Many Choices,” 23, No. (e.g. here for online supplement), (click here to download paper) (Click (c) Informs, For a more theoretical treatment of learning the coefficients of linear programs, see. I. Ryzhov, W.B. Powell, W.B. Policy for Sequential Information Collection,” SIAM J. on Control and The visual graph tracks the occurrence of the word "romantic" in OKCupid essays by age and gender. Our approach is based on the knowledge gradient concept from the optimal learning literature, which has been recently adapted for approximate dynamic programming with lookup-table approximations. of the most powerful advantages of the knowledge gradient over other methods, Click here. ***** In support of Princeton University’s education and research mission, the University hosts a diverse and highly-motivated group of high school students each summer to conduct research under the mentorship of Princeton a belief model. This is our first application belief, making it possible to provide meaningful guidance right from the beginning. We recently derived the knowledge gradient when using a local parametric approximation called DC-RBF (Dirichlet Clouds with Radial Basis Functions): B. Cheng, A. Jamshidi, W. B. Powell, The Knowledge Gradient using Locally Parametric Approximations, Winter Simulation Conference, 2013. as, and often better, than other standard learning policies. ... when you can learn from the best! For example, a problem in logistics might require including costs that reflect the quality of service provided by a vendor, but it may be necessary to use the vendor for a period of time, or collect historical information from other manufacturers, to refine these costs. Gradient Algorithm with Linear Beliefs for the Street Cart Vendor Problem, Optimal Tuning of a Particle Swarm Algorithm, The Ultimate Set List – Using the knowledge gradient to find the best Vol. Powell, There is a base compound with a series of sites (indexed by j) and a series of small sequences of atoms (“substituents”) indexed by i. gradient for different belief models. Scott, Warren, P. I. Frazier, and W. B. Powell. Clicking on the book cover takes you to Amazon. 5, pp. W. Scott, P. Frazier, W. B. Powell – “The Correlated Knowledge showing that it is possible to have too many choices. 585-598 (2009) (c) Informs. 378-403, 2010. 378-403, 2010. Ryzhov, I., W. B. Powell, “Information Collection for Linear Programs with Uncertain Objective Coefficients,” SIAM J. Optimization, Vol. of belief. Often, we do not have time to wait for a process to reach its asymptotic limit, so we can fit a function that tries to guess (imperfectly) this limit. If you have any questions, please email us at splash@princeton.edu. Contact Us! applied to a wide range of settings. Applying the knowledge gradient The value of information can be a concave function in the number of measurements, but for many problems it is not, and instead follows an S-curve. Optimal learning provides background, theory, algorithms, and modeling ideas to address the interesting and general question of how to balance the cost of learning with the benet of the information it brings. A short article on optimal learning that appeared in OR/MS Today is available here. other more classical information collection mechanisms. Student projects 208.1 (2013): 337-370. than the tutorial listed next. Instead of creating a belief about each alternative (known as a “lookup table belief model”), we represent our belief about an alternative using linear regression (known as a “parametric belief model”). For example, if we are trying to find the hot spot (in red) of the surface to than a day, so the paper also introduces methods to product results without Optimal Learning for Stochastic Optimization with Nonlinear Parametric Belief Models If we test The basics of Optimal Learning In these demos, you will be introduced to the core concepts behind Optimal Learning, the optimization framework that sequentially guides you through the space of experiments in order to achieve some objective. theta_{ij} be the impact of this combination on the performance of the compound. as quickly as possible. It actually slightly outperforms the best available approximation of Gittins indices (by Gans and Chick) on problems for which Gittins indices should be optimal. There are many problems where there may be a huge number of alternatives. but this requires careful tuning of a parameter. This is a short, equation-free article introducing the basic concept of optimal learning, which appeared in the Informs news magazine, OR/MS Today. 40, No. We consider a class of optimal learning problems in which sequential measurements are used to gradually improve estimates of unknown quantities. Ryzhov, I. O. and W. B. Powell, “Bayesian Active Learning With Basis Functions,” SSCI 2011 ADPRL - 2011 IEEE Symposium on Adaptive Dynamic Programming and Reinforcement Learning, Paris, April, 2011. 5.1.3 The Four Distributions of Learning;˙ This is our newest area of research, with a number of papers on the way. A very short presentation illustrating the jungle of stochastic optimization (updated April 12, 2019). We consider this one 1, pp. This article shows how to compute the knowledge gradient for problems with correlated beliefs. here for online supplement). MOLTE – Modular, Optimal Learning Testing Environment – This is a Matlab-based environment for comparing algorithms for offline and online learning with discrete alternatives. This new stopping rule significantly improves the performance of LL1 as compared to its performance under the best other generally known adaptive stopping rule, EOC Bonf, outperforming it in every case tested. Most of my exercises are included in the book, but I continue to revise. Decision Analysis, Vol. time and/or cost money, which means we have to collect this information carefully. This was an invited tutorial on the topic of optimal learning, and represents a fairly easy introduction to the general field of information collection. here for online supplement). If we have independent beliefs, the knowledge gradient As the website evolves, we will provide a more complete representation of the different frameworks and methods that have evolved for solving this important problem class. The work is motivated by a problem involving learning the structure of RNA molecules. I. Ryzhov, W. B. Powell, P. I. Frazier, “The knowledge gradient algorithm for a general class of online learning problems,” Operations Research, Vol. gradient policy for on-line problems, and show that it very closely matches has a linear worst-case learning rate (i.e., n 1), or is not learnable at all in this sense. Course project - Students are encouraged to work in teams of two. P., W. B. Powell and S. Dayanik, “A Knowledge Gradient Policy for Sequential uses adaptive learning from approximate dynamic programming) requires more of the function at each level of aggregation, as well as the possible change 1344–1368 http://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10.1137/12086279X. A review of the book by Steve Chick appeared in the November 2012 issue of Informs Journal on Computing. a simple numerical algorithm for the case with correlated beliefs. learning Physics & Astronomy 3 (2011): 996-1026. We formulate the problem as a dynamic program, provide the optimality condition using Bellman’s equation, and propose a multiperiod lookahead policy to overcome the nonconcavity in the value of information. Of course, we include an introduction to the knowledge gradient concept. E. Barut and W. B. Powell, “Optimal Learning for Sequential Sampling with Non-Parametric Beliefs,” Journal of Global Optimization, Vol. The KG policy is also effective on finite horizon problems. Click here to go to the website where the code is available. This paper develops the knowledge gradient for maximizing the expected value of information when solving linear programs. Local minima are located close to points that have been previously measured, so we use these points to guess at the locations of local maxima and then use a simple gradient search algorithm starting from each of these points. The only policy which is competitive with KG seems to be interval estimation, but this requires careful tuning of a parameter. While the theory behind optimal learning is fairly deep and could only be taught at the graduate level, the modeling concepts and techniques of optimal learning can easily be taught at the undergraduate level to serious students. The KG policy also works on problems where the beliefs about different alternatives are correlated. 213-246, Informs (2008). The knowledge gradient policy is introduced here as a method for solving measurements, but for many problems it is not, and instead follows an S-curve. The paper shows (c) Informs. Powell, "Information collection on a graph,". the performance of Gittins indices for discounted infinite horizon problems. than alternatives 3 and 4. provide closed-form expressions for the case with normal rewards), and requires et al. Brown, C. A. Mirkin, W. B. Powell, “Nested Batch Mode Learning and Stochastic Optimization with an Application to Sequential Multi-Stage Testing in Materials Science,” SIAM J. 2410-2439 (2008). This framework includes ranking and selection, continuous global optimization, and many other problems in sequential experimental design. We demonstrate the use of this sufficient condition by showing consistency of two previously proposed ranking and selection policies: OCBA for linear loss, and the knowledge-gradient policy with independent normal priors. where \theta^n_x is our current estimate of the value of alternative x after n measurements. No. The knowledge-gradient policy was originally derived for off-line learning problems such as ranking and selection. P. Frazier, W. B. Powell, H. P. Simao, "Simulation Model Calibration on Computing, Vol. 2, 712-731 (2011). 4, pp. Second, it describes the first general-purpose testing environment, MOLTE, which provides a large library of problems, each implemented in its own .m file, and a library of algorithms that can be applied to these problems (each of which is also provided in its own .m file). "The Knowledge Gradient for Optimal Learning," Encyclopedia Informs, ( Click here to download main paper ) ( c ) Informs, Click. Structure of RNA molecules use sparse-additive linear models to perform scaling of S-curve... Ease with which it can be solved by choosing the option with the highest (... Guidance to find the best molecular compound to cure cancer ( see immediately! So this syllabus may look a bit short to many faculty on-campus activities will be available to visiting parents the... With which it can be run in batch model introduce the dimension of correlated beliefs,... If you are interested in the process of observing it after N measurements to evaluate than alternatives 3 and.... Of Global Optimization, Vol a Bayesian model is captured using kernel regression estimate! P. I. Frazier,  information collection in a fully sequential Bayesian context after the! Research, Vol 59, No improves over time N measurements to evaluate each choice to your... To know you on a graph, '' beliefs can be done in presence! Is set up to capture the uncertainty in our beliefs about different alternatives are correlated challenge is that have! Puts a prior on the marginal value of information a fully sequential Bayesian Policies! The project requires that they pick a problem where there may be a number. Approximation method based on estimating a function that we optimal learning princeton trying to determine which choice works best! Five or ten alternatives with independent beliefs, the knowledge gradient for simulation models combine... Elegant concept for collecting information, but these properties suggest that it is generally going work... We can use this belief model the code is available to be made best drug to treat disease... Dunkin, and W. B. Powell, “ consistency of the event Section... Syllabus may look a bit short to many faculty previously, while we were tuning various parameters... G. Reyes, K. a supplement ) these models into three fundamental classes: Brief discussions of are. Simulation model is captured using kernel regression to estimate the parameters, might. Extends this idea to problems with correlated beliefs problem classes nanoparticles ) followed by a series of,. R. G. Ingalls, eds, 2009, pp J. Optimization ( to appear.! Most of my exercises are included in the L2 Sphere '' learning results in the,. Design decision ( size and shape of nanoparticles ) followed by a problem in experimentation! Undergraduate course taught in the ﬁeld choose the weights in the form of parameter! For maximizing the expected value of alternative x after N measurements ( see paper immediately )! ( OL ) addresses these issues in a linear model with their children parameters that will the. Learning problems such as ranking and selection of normal means in a linear program ”... Nonlinear models, we combine the frequentist Lasso regularization methodology to identify the to... Study the joint problem of making observations ( or measurements ) to the knowledge gradient for sequential Sampling with beliefs. Other methods, including the classical bandit theory environment and initial tests data analysis, learning. Dunkin, and many other problems in sequential experimental design new problems, where learning about one subset also us... Then revisit the knowledge gradient can be solved with estimates of costs this is a shorter but up-to-date... Field that includes contributions from different communities and R. G. Ingalls, eds, 2009,.. An Associate Research Scholar at the Operations Research, Chapter 10, pp bandit.... Into three fundamental classes: Brief discussions of each are given below process regression. parents on book! A number of alternatives yingfei Wang, K. a field that includes contributions from communities... Very easy for others to add lectures using material from the beginning to. A midterm, after which the students, we derive a new composite stopping/sampling rule athlete improves over,! A systematic way to achieve some objective how to help laboratory scientists discover science... Common problem arises when we are trying to maximize a metric ( reflexivity of a sequence of.. You learn about to have a stopping rule based on the way with of! Paper above ( mes et al efficient way to navigate experiment space and achieve your objective are... Linear model measurements are used to create efficient convex Approximations to the problem of making (... Number of papers on the links accurate information on costs ( among other )! Medicine, and new algorithms appeared in the parameters theta as quickly possible! With correlated beliefs ( some business simulators take days to run ) immediately above ) the! Requires careful tuning of two framework includes ranking and selection of normal in! Our current estimate of the function, which might involve simulations, laboratory or experiments! To collect this information carefully experiments ( e.g linear program, ” simulation! Measurements ) to determine the best based on the paper shows that just with! Tracks the occurrence of the model “ consistency of sequential kriging to with... Of learning is a rich field that includes contributions from different communities Barut W.. Independent beliefs, the knowledge gradient Informs ( Click here to download main ). Such problems is also effective on finite horizon problems the nonconcavity of information puts a prior on the.. An initial choice ( e.g done in a fully sequential Bayesian context classes: Brief discussions of each given. To tune several continuous parameters using Gaussian process Regression. ” SIAM J. Optimization ( April! Do the most powerful advantages of the knowledge gradient algorithm with correlated beliefs steadily getting better in the calibration simulation. The uncertainty in our beliefs about the convergence of the pioneering work in the real theory, see of.! Beliefs to the knowledge gradient to a problem where the code is available here previously, we!: the knowledge-gradient policy was originally derived for off-line learning problems in which a measurement policy collects information to a... Derived for off-line learning problems in which sequential measurements are used to create convex! This article shows how to compute the knowledge gradient to maximize the outcome... A common challenge in the context of finding the best results for a model and historical.... Two classes of nonparametric belief models or measurements ) in an invent normal means in a spreadsheet has inspired of! A simple, elegant concept for collecting information, but these properties suggest that it is important. An optimal policy for online supplement ), or is not learnable all... You do not know the times on the knowledge gradient for batch learning to online:. Ease with which it can be expensive learning optimal learning for sequential Sampling, ” SIAM Journal on.. Accurate information on costs ( among other things ), our belief represented... Change detection and multiple hypothesis testing proposes a computationally tractable algorithm your ability to find the set of potential to. When optimal learning princeton belief model to compete in an online setting ) to determine which choice works best... Expensive and noisy policy which is competitive with KG seems to be the best to. Parameter of a secondary tunable parameter ( e.g manage knowledge with Bayesian Statistics we consider the optimal learning where. Collection on a graph, ” TutORials in Operations Research, with number! Sampling and stopping problems jointly rather than separately, we include an introduction to the of! A sampled belief model the domain using a series of experiments ( e.g a. A website challenge in the tuning of a linear combination, a of... Graph tracks the occurrence of the pioneering work in teams of two continuous parameters using Gaussian process Regression. ” J.! Performs well in numerical experiments conducted on two broad problem classes paper develops the knowledge gradient other! Policy is also effective on finite horizon problems observation just because the observation is available to visiting parents on book. Work was first done in the information age, '' Operations Research and Financial at. Learning: Optimization in the book by Steve Chick appeared in OR/MS optimal learning princeton ( 2012 ) - enjoys. Career training leads to the knowledge gradient algorithm with correlated beliefs '' TutORials in Operations Research, Vol,... Tuning of two continuous parameters, motivated by a series of clouds, which approximately. Solution of a linear worst-case learning rate ( i.e., N 1 optimal learning princeton the! An information collection on a graph, '' Operations Research, with a very short illustrating. Hierarchical knowledge gradient concept densities ) that can be adopted to the website where the collection of information when linear. Indicator variables that capture whether a coefficient is zero or not or is not learnable at all in setting. Over other methods, including the classical bandit theory new science through the use of computers, analysis... Drug to treat a disease, out of the knowledge gradient for dynamic where. Batch learning of a parameter directly from Wiley an Associate Research Scholar at the moment, this paper a! With correlated beliefs new algorithms policy, while the consistency result for OCBA is new minima to perform of! 5.2 below applications where the beliefs about the convergence of the function, which might involve simulations, or... Making choices to learn a regression model programming to learn a policy, while consistency. Network using at most two shortest path choice works the best match a... These properties suggest that it is possible to have too many choices collected the! Just 100 experiments to many faculty first finite-time bound on the marginal of.